Why Bing Just Blocked 1.5 Million Independent Websites

1.5 million independent websites vanished from search results overnight. Microsoft'sBing had inexplicably blocked every site hosted on Neocities, effectively erasing one of the internet's most vibrant creative communities.

Neocities isn't just another web hosting platform. Founded in 2013 to preserve the "aesthetic awesomeness" of GeoCities, it's where the 1990s internet spirit lives on. Here, hundreds of thousands of users craft deeply personal websites filled with spinning GIFs, custom CSS experiments, and unabashed creativity—a stark contrast to the sterile uniformity of modern social media.

For artists, niche fandom communities, and anyone seeking to express themselves beyond the constraints of Facebook templates, Neocities offers something increasingly rare: a blank digital canvas where personality trumps algorithms.

The Block That Wasn't Supposed to Happen

The trouble started last summer when Kyle Drake, Neocities' founder, noticed Bing was blocking their sites. After contacting Microsoft, the issue seemed resolved. But in January 2025, users reported login problems—and Drake discovered a complete block had been reimplemented.

The situation grew more alarming. Not only had Bing delisted Neocities' homepage, but it began directing users to a copycat site where unsuspecting visitors were entering their login credentials. What started as a search visibility issue had become a potential security nightmare.

Microsoft hasn't provided a clear explanation for the blocks, leaving the Neocities community in digital limbo. For many users, Bing might seem like a secondary concern—but this incident reveals something more troubling about how search engines wield power over information access.

When Algorithms Decide What Exists

This isn't just about one quirky corner of the internet. It's about who controls what we can find online. When a handful of search engines can unilaterally decide that 1.5 million websites don't deserve to exist in search results, we're witnessing a fundamental shift in how information flows.

The Neocities block highlights a growing tension between search engines' desire for "quality control" and the internet's foundational promise of open access. As AI increasingly powers search algorithms, these automated decisions become more opaque and potentially more arbitrary.

For web developers and small site owners, this represents an existential threat. If your site doesn't fit algorithmic expectations—if it's too creative, too niche, or simply too different—it might simply disappear from the digital map.

The Homogenization of Discovery

What makes the Neocities situation particularly concerning is what it represents: the gradual erosion of internet diversity. While major platforms optimize for engagement and ad revenue, independent sites like those on Neocities prioritize expression and community over metrics.

These sites serve as testing grounds for new web technologies, archives of internet culture, and gathering places for communities that don't fit mainstream molds. When search engines block them en masse, we lose more than just websites—we lose laboratories of digital creativity.

The incident also raises questions about search engine accountability. Unlike traditional media, search algorithms operate with little transparency or oversight. When they make mistakes—or implement policies that disproportionately affect certain communities—there's often no clear recourse.

The Future of Independent Web

As search engines become more sophisticated, they're also becoming more selective. This creates a paradox: the tools designed to help us find information are increasingly limiting what we can discover.

For internet freedom advocates, the Neocities block serves as a warning. If search engines can arbitrarily exclude entire platforms, what prevents them from gradually narrowing the scope of discoverable content to only the largest, most commercial sites?

The situation also highlights our growing dependence on a small number of search providers. While users can still access Neocities sites directly, the reality is that most web discovery happens through search. When that pipeline closes, even the most creative content becomes effectively invisible.

The Neocities incident forces us to confront an uncomfortable question: In an age of infinite information, is the greatest threat to knowledge not censorship, but simply being ignored by the algorithms that decide what exists?