Minneapolis Resistance Breaks Trump's Disinformation Machine

Two innocent Americans were gunned down in Minneapolis. Alex Pretti, on his knees and restrained, was riddled with 10 bullets in 5 seconds. Renee Good was shot point-blank in the head. Yet this tragedy has delivered an unexpected blow to the Trump administration—not through the killings themselves, but through what happened next.

When Lies Stop Working

The administration's response was predictable and vicious. Dead victims became "domestic terrorists." Pretti was labeled a "would-be assassin" by Stephen Miller, Trump's most influential aide. Grieving families were forced to defend their loved ones against "sickening" and "reprehensible" government lies.

But something unprecedented happened: the gaslighting failed.

For 10 years, Trump has successfully warped reality for vast swaths of America. From the January 6th Capitol assault to claims of a "stolen" 2020 election, his administration has weaponized lies with devastating effectiveness. This time was different.

Multiple videos of the execution-like killings made denial impossible. Even Trump, perhaps sensing the futility, left the lying to subordinates with far less credibility among his base. The administration found itself in retreat, reportedly more frustrated with media coverage than with the killings themselves.

The Minneapolis Formula

What emerged from this horror was a new model of resistance. Minneapolis citizens combined peaceful mass protests with sophisticated citizen surveillance, primarily through smartphone recordings. This served a "double purpose," as The New York Times noted: capturing evidence while controlling the narrative.

Residents distributed whistles to alert neighbors about ICE locations. They practiced what scholar Adam Serwer calls "neighborism"—protecting people around you regardless of whether they were born in Minneapolis or Mogadishu.

The results were immediate. Tens of thousands of volunteers risked their safety to defend neighbors and freedom. Federal agents began withdrawing from Minneapolis. The administration's massive, multifront assault on truth—perhaps its greatest weapon—had been blunted.

Sponsored

Advertise with Us

[email protected]

Sponsored

Why Reconciliation Must Wait

This victory teaches a crucial lesson about American polarization: genuine reconciliation requires defeating injustice first, not bridging differences with it.

South Africa's Truth and Reconciliation Commission succeeded only after the apartheid government was defeated. Nelson Mandela and Bishop Desmond Tutu's moral appeals moved hearts only once their oppressors had lost power.

The Trump coalition isn't interested in decreasing polarization or increasing mutual understanding. Even evangelical Christian communities—where one might expect to find a "ministry of reconciliation"—have been consumed by "pulsating resentments and overpowering hatreds," as pastors privately admit.

We cannot implant generosity of spirit in those who see it as weakness. Isaiah's injunction to "come now, and let us reason together" doesn't apply when emotions are inflamed and power is being abused.

The Broader Battle

Minneapolis may signal tactical retreat, but the larger assault continues. We still have three years left in Trump's second term, and as one retired police captain observed, sending politicized federal forces into cities uninvited serves a bigger scheme—normalizing military presence on American streets while keeping immigration fears at fever pitch.

Yet Minneapolis has provided something invaluable: proof that organized, nonviolent resistance works. As scholars Erica Chenoweth and Maria Stephan note in Why Civil Resistance Works, such movements can shift loyalty even among supporters of repressive regimes, including military members.

Songs of Resistance

Bruce Springsteen captured the moment in "Streets of Minneapolis," dedicated to the city's people and the memory of Alex Pretti and Renee Good:

"Oh, our Minneapolis, I hear your voiceSinging through the bloody mistHere in our home they killed and roamedIn the winter of '26We'll take our stand for this landAnd the stranger in our midst"

Pretti and Good died too young, standing against too much injustice. Whether their deaths inspire others to "push back the darkness" depends on the rest of us.