Gaza's Last Hostage Exchange: When Peace Becomes the Real Challenge

15 bodies for one. That's how the final chapter of Gaza's hostage crisis ended on Thursday, but the math reveals everything wrong with calling this "resolution."

The International Committee of the Red Cross facilitated the exchange of 15 Palestinian bodies for the remains of Ran Gvili, an Israeli policeman killed during the Hamas-led October 7, 2023 attacks. With this exchange, all 251 captives taken that day have been returned to Israel, marking the end of a 2-year, 4-month ordeal that defined much of the war.

The Unbalanced Equation

While Israel mourns its last returned hostage—Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu called Gvili a "hero of Israel" and warned enemies of heavy consequences for future attacks—the broader picture tells a different story about justice and accountability.

Thousands of Palestinian prisoners remain in Israeli jails, many without charges or trials. A July 2024 UN Human Rights Office report found Israel holding approximately 9,400 Palestinians as "security detainees," often without explaining their detention, in facilities where torture and sexual assault are widespread.

Physicians for Human Rights-Israel reported in November that at least 94 Palestinian prisoners have died in Israeli custody from torture, medical neglect, malnutrition, and assault. The actual number is likely much higher, they noted.

When Numbers Tell the Story

The Haaretz newspaper reported Thursday that the Israeli army "has adopted for the first time the Gaza Health Ministry's count of nearly 70,000 Palestinians killed during the war"—figures Israel had previously disputed. The current death toll exceeds 71,000.

Even as the hostage exchanges conclude, violence continues. On Thursday, mourners buried two Palestinians killed by Israeli gunfire in Khan Younis, outside the "yellow line" marking the 58% of Gaza still under Israeli occupation.

The Governance Gamble

With hostage exchanges complete, attention turns to Gaza's political future. The US-brokered ceasefire calls for a committee of Palestinian technocrats to assume day-to-day governance of the enclave.

Hamas spokesman Hazem Qassem declared readiness for the transition: "Protocols are prepared, files are complete and committees are in place to oversee the handover, ensuring a complete transfer of governance in the Gaza Strip across all sectors."

This committee will work under the Board of Peace, created and chaired by US President Donald Trump. The work promises to be extraordinarily difficult.

The Catastrophe Continues

Gaza's Civil Defence spokesman Mahmoud Basal warned Thursday of an "unprecedented catastrophe" due to lack of shelter and food, plus medical supply shortages from the continued Israeli blockade.

Palestinians await the reopening of the Rafah crossing with Egypt, which Washington has pushed Israel to allow as part of the ceasefire agreement.