Did Davey Scatino Kill Tony Soprano? Robert Patrick Breaks Silence on the Viral Finale Theory

It's been decades since the screen cut to black, but the debate over Tony Soprano's fate hasn't aged a day. Now, Robert Patrick, who played the tragic gambling addict Davey Scatino in The SopranosSeason 2, is finally responding to a long-standing fan theory: was he the one who pulled the trigger in that infamous diner?

The Man in the Diner: Fan Theories and Facts

According to Entertainment Weekly, many viewers have speculated that a man seen in the series finale looked suspiciously like Davey, the childhood friend whose life was systematically destroyed by Tony. Speaking to TV Insider, Patrick admitted he wasn't even aware of the theory. "I feel blessed that people would really still be thinking about my character at the end," he said, though he confirmed that showrunner David Chase never contacted him about a finale cameo.

Davey’s downfall was one of the show's most brutal arcs. After losing everything in a high-stakes poker game, Tony busted out Davey's sporting goods store, leaving him bankrupt and alone. Despite appearing in only 3 episodes, Patrick's performance left a lasting mark on the fandom, fueling the revenge narrative for years.

A Tribute to James Gandolfini in 'Tulsa King'

Patrick also shared a surprising connection between the HBO classic and his current role in Tulsa King. In Season 3, he threw a specific line at Sylvester Stallone's character: "How's your balls, Manfredi?" This wasn't just random dialogue—it was a direct tribute to the late James Gandolfini.

The actor recalled how Gandolfini used that exact phrase to break the ice and "scare the living s---" out of him before a intense scene in The Sopranos. Reusing the line in Tulsa King was a conscious effort to bridge the two mafia worlds for the fans and honor his former co-star.