Simon Cowell Reflects on Kelly Clarkson American Idol Win: 'It Was Like a Movie'

Reality TV isn't always real, but sometimes it captures lightning in a bottle. Legenday judge Simon Cowell recently looked back at the 23-year legacy of the Kelly Clarkson American Idol win, describing it as a "dream-like" cinematic moment that saved the franchise from disaster.

Simon Cowell Kelly Clarkson American Idol Win Retrospective

Speaking on the Rolling Stone Music Now podcast, Cowell didn't hold back about the show's shaky beginnings. He admitted he initially thought the series would be a "disaster" after seeing terrible auditions in the first few cities. However, the emergence of Clarkson changed everything. According to Cowell, she was the "perfect winner" who validated the entire concept of talent competitions. Since that fateful night on September 4, 2002, Clarkson has gone on to win 3 Grammys and 7 Emmys for her talk show, proving that her talent was no fluke.

A Legacy of Validation and Friendship

Cowell also shared some characteristically blunt critiques, noting he wished Tamyra Gray had faced Clarkson in the finale instead of runner-up Justin Guarini. Despite his critiques of others, his praise for Clarkson remains unwavering. He credited her for the show's 23-year longevity, stating that her success gave the judges and the network a reason to keep going. Their bond remains strong today, as evidenced by Cowell honoring her at her Hollywood Walk of Fame ceremony in 2022, where he noted that the person fans see on camera is exactly who she is behind the scenes.