Grandma's Dust-Collector? Precious Moments Figurine Resale Value Guide

That dusty porcelain doll sitting on your grandmother's dining room shelf could be your next big payday. According to Facts Verse, certain Precious Moments figurines from the late 1970s are now fetching over $1,300 on the resale market, turning nostalgic giftware into serious assets.

Precious Moments Figurine Resale Value: The 'Original 21' Goldmine

The holy grail for collectors is the Original 21, the very first batch released in 1978. Created by artist Samuel J. Butcher, these early pieces were sold under the name Jonathan & David. Because most were retired shortly after their debut, finding an authentic, mint-condition original is a rare feat that commands high prices on platforms like eBay.

Most Valuable Models to Watch For

• God Loveth A Cheerful Giver: This model is often cited as the most valuable, with signed or rare typo versions selling for between $275 and $1,300+.
• Disney's Cinderella Carriage: Limited editions or special collaborations have reached price points as high as $1,500.
• Come Let Us Adore Him: A retired early 1980s piece frequently valued near $375.

While most modern versions sell for about $40, the value of vintage pieces lies in their scarcity and historical markers. Authenticity certificates and original boxes can significantly boost the final sale price, as the market is driven by collectors looking to preserve a piece of 1980s culture.