The J.Y. Park Mental Health Advice Controversy: Professionalism or Toxic Positivity?

Should idols prioritize the group's atmosphere over their own mental struggles? This question has sparked a global debate following comments made by J.Y. Park, the founder of JYP Entertainment. His philosophy on maintaining a cheerful demeanor, even during personal crises, continues to resonate as a controversial flashpoint in the K-pop industry as of January 2026.

The J.Y. Park Mental Health Advice Controversy Explained

According to Billboard and viral social media clips from the PSICK SHOW, Park shared that he tells artists like Stray Kids and TWICE that appearing depressed or sad makes others uncomfortable. He suggested that even on their toughest days, idols should crack jokes to ensure everyone around them feels at ease. Fans quickly condemned this as an encouragement of "emotional suppression," arguing it treats human beings like emotionless robots.

Real-World Consequences: ITZY Lia and the Hiatus Trend

The debate intensified when ITZY member Lia went on a hiatus in 2023 due to severe anxiety. Fans pointed out the irony of Park's advice, suggesting that a culture of hiding pain could be why so many idols eventually reach a breaking point. However, a segment of the fandom argues that public perception is paramount in the entertainment industry. They believe that maintaining a professional front is a necessary sacrifice for the collective success of a group.