"Can we watch it again?" Neil Diamond's emotional reaction to 'Song Sung Blue' (Neil Diamond Song Sung Blue reaction 2026)

Even the "Believer" himself couldn't hold back the tears. Neil Diamond, the legendary singer-songwriter, just gave the ultimate seal of approval to the new film inspired by his legacy. After a private screening, Diamond didn't just walk away—he asked to see it all over again.

Neil Diamond Song Sung Blue Reaction 2026: A Legend Moved to Tears

Directed by Craig Brewer and starring Hugh Jackman and Kate Hudson, Song Sung Blue tells the true story of Mike and Claire Sardina. These two Wisconsinites formed a Neil Diamond tribute band called Lightning & Thunder, finding love and local stardom through Diamond's iconic catalog.

Brewer shared with Entertainment Weekly that Diamond's reaction was far from the neutral study they expected. Diamond was seen tapping his feet and applauding after every musical number. "He went up to the projectionist and said, 'Okay, well, when's the next screening? Can we watch it again?'" Brewer recalled, noting that the 84-year-old icon was visibly moved to tears by the portrayal of his impact on everyday lives.

The Eddie Vedder Connection and Music Rights

The film also highlights a surprising piece of music history from 1995. Pearl Jam's Eddie Vedder was a major supporter of the Sardinas, even inviting them to perform during an encore at Milwaukee's Summerfest. Years later, when a documentary about the couple faced a cease-and-desist over music rights, it was Vedder who called Diamond personally to champion their story. That intervention paved the way for the music to live on in this new cinematic tribute.