The AI Fear Trade Is Coming for Your Portfolio

Monday Morning Reckoning

Wall Street opened the week in full defense mode. The Nasdaq dropped nearly 1% in early trading, with the S&P 500 down 0.8% and the Dow falling 0.4%. But this wasn't your typical tech selloff confined to the usual suspects.

Nvidia fell 1.6%, Microsoft and Palantir dropped 1.3% and 1.2% respectively, while Advanced Micro Devices plummeted almost 5%. Even Amazon, a cloud and AI powerhouse, couldn't escape the selling pressure.

Investors are no longer treating AI as a distant threat—they're acting like it's close enough to the revenue line to matter. Right now.

Hunting for Expensive Human Processes

The market has turned into a scanning machine, searching for businesses that sell "expensive human processes." The logic is brutal but simple: if AI agents can handle end-to-end workflows—planning, searching, comparing, synthesizing, executing—then companies making money as toll collectors start looking less inevitable.

Recent product launches are making this fear tangible. Wealth-management platform Altruist rolled out AI-enabled tax planning. Insurance marketplace Insurify launched a ChatGPT-style comparison tool. Each announcement triggered selling in brokerages and insurance intermediaries as investors asked the uncomfortable question: "If software can handle more of the workflow, what happens to the fee?"

Beyond Fintech's Borders

The "AI scare trade" has jumped industries like a contagion. It's now hitting private credit exposure tied to software companies, financial intermediaries, data firms, real estate services, insurance brokers—even trucking and logistics after an AI freight tool spooked the entire sector.

When a narrative starts crossing industry lines like this, it stops being about individual stocks and becomes market behavior. The S&P software and services group has shed roughly $2 trillion since its October peak, with much of that damage concentrated in recent weeks.

BNP Paribas analysts estimate that about one-fifth of private credit exposure is tied to software, explaining why alternative asset managers have been swept into this turbulence.

The Strategist Split

Wall Street's crystal ball is cloudy. Jefferies economist Mohit Kumar frames this as rotation—capital moving between winners and losers rather than fleeing equities entirely. JPMorgan Chase strategist Dubravko Lakos-Bujas argues markets may be pricing in worst-case disruption scenarios, creating rebound opportunities in higher-quality software.

Meanwhile, Morgan Stanley's Daniel Skelly recently described what we're seeing as a "bull market in disruption hysteria."

The Margin Compression Question

Here's what makes this moment different: the market can believe two contradictory things simultaneously. That AI will drive massive spending on chips, cloud infrastructure, and data centers. And that AI will take a razor blade to certain profit pools.

On ugly mornings like Monday, investors sell both the supposed "victims" and the obvious "enablers" because uncertainty is contagious and positioning is a blunt instrument.